“If I
were you...”
This
statement is normally accompanied by a severely wagged index finger.
Many
times, in various ‘Blogs’ I have mentioned this. It is one of my most hated
expressions.
The
problem with it is that the person making this admonition is not ‘you’. That
person is giving advice based on their needs, their wants and their
experiences. It is not related to anything for which you wish.
Since I
have admitted to already speaking of this on multiple occasions, why am I
bringing it up again now?
Because,
dear hearts, it presented itself in stark terms twice on ‘Facebook’. Today.
In one
instance a person was advised they should follow a certain course of action.
We all, I
am sure, have a Mrs Youshould in your lives. It might be a Mr. Youshould, of
course, but, either way, there is always somebody out there who is so bored
with their own lives that they feel obliged to control yours.
The sad
part about this is that, very often, the effect is rather more subtle than
somebody coming along and proffering unwanted words of wisdom.
Sometimes
the damage is done at an early age and make no mistake about it, it is damage
that lasts and lasts.
Children
in rural areas, I cannot speak for those in more urban parts—perhaps they are
afflicted in the same manner, are often part of a feudal system that has been
handed down to us by the Vikings. Well, alright, they were called ‘Normans' by
then.
These
people invaded what was then Britain and set up a system of overlords that
ruled over the ‘People of the Knife’ (Saxons) with an iron fist.
It is
from this racism that we get the likes of Robin Hood and his, possibly less
than, Merry Men.
This
framework of subjugated fealty develops into what we now have in the United
Kingdom, it is the Aristocracy.
These
people are our ‘betters’. We are supposed to tug a forelock, or two, when they
sweep grandly past us. Our parents and others tell us that they, the Lords and
Ladies of the Realm, are better than us; we should cast our eyes down and gaze
longingly at the dirt in their presence.
Similarly,
when presented with a puzzle we might be told that ‘better people than you have
tried to find a cure/solution for that’ leaving you to crawl back into your
inferiority.
Forty-odd
years ago I was writing an article for a local magazine every month. A cartoon
accompanied this. Never missed a month in five years. The article was always
sent through the mail in order to reach the editorial office by deadline day.
Never missed.
After two
years I decided to write a short story for the magazine. Very short. Possibly
it was no more than a thousand words (these ‘Blogs’ are generally around eight hundred to a thousand words). After this length of time I can no longer remember
what the story was about but, presumably, it would have been stunningly
brilliant—as you might expect.
This time
I took it to the editorial office personally and put it on the desk of the
Officer who was the Editor.
He looked
puzzled and then asked me what it was. He never touched it, perhaps he thought
he might receive some dire disease from it.
I told
him that it was a story. A story for the magazine.
A look of
astonishment crossed his face—he looked up at me and said, “I hardly think that
a Corporal in the Technical Branch can string together sufficient words to form
a cohesive sentence let alone write a story.”
He
laughed. At me.
I picked
up the story and left.
Such is
the arrogance engendered by a class system that makes people born into leadership believe that they
are better than their minions. It is what is driven into our heads at an early
age. We grow up with certain ideas. Ideas that tell us that we can never be as
good as the boy next door or the girl in the pageant.
It is
ingrained into us. The subservience, the inferiority, is part of the system that
we live in.
It occurs
now. People are accustomed to being in debt. Debt is the comfort level for most
people.
You can
give someone a large sum of money and they will fritter it away until they are
back in debt. Of course, it will be your fault because you gave them insufficient
funds in the first place!
Debt is
comfortable because that is how the children see life from an early age. For
them the gap between the ‘haves’ and the ‘have nots’ is normal, it is a natural
occurrence.
Traditionally,
where I come from, real men get on the bus in the morning with a bag of tools,
a lunch pack and a ‘Thermos’ flask to go and do a proper day’s work. They are
Tradesmen. Real tradesmen.
I was in
the military and now teach people and write stories for a living—in those
people’s eyes I am a failure. It doesn’t matter whether I have money or not, I
have not succeeded in life.
There is
the root of the problem.
That
grinding of ideas into children’s heads that there are better people out there.
Older people, sometimes, who know better.
You
should always take their advice. Woe betide you if you do not do as you are
told!
“If I was
you...”
Then they
become upset if you don’t take their advice.
But
advice is like any other gift, you can take it or leave it. You can modify it—do
as you wish with it. Once it has left the donor it has nothing to do with that
person.
A word of
advice on giving advice. Never give advice.
If you
give advice and someone accepts it then their World turns to worms it will be
your fault.
If I was
you I should never give advice.
Note: "If I was you..." is colloquial. Clearly the correct form is "If I WERE you..."
ReplyDeleteJust to make sure that you are aware of my understanding of English and that the second form at the end is deliberate.
Thank you.
Another case in point is the Johor Sultanate. They and a few other royalties prefer to marry a white male or female so that their children will look more Caucasian, not brown like the locals. This will help engender feelings of superiority over the locals forcing them at the psychological level to be subservient to the royals, reminincent of the old collonial days where English/Dutch/Portugese were the overlords.Most of them are tall and fair and quite intimidating to the local folks, such as the Raja Muda of Johor who has quite a reputation with his uncouth behaviour as well as his temper. I have first hand experience with this. My Manchester born friend James 'Jaffar' Greaves married into one. The sultan of Negri Sembilan's granddaughter
ReplyDeleteRoyalty? Doesn't their poo stink as well?
More here>>>> http://johorsultan.blogspot.com/search/label/Controversies
PS. My ancestors were Kshatriyas or Satrias, knights or rulers at one time in India. We were very powerful then but we blew it. It was because of the proverbial 'killing the goose that laid the golden egg' kind of scenario. We sold our souls first to the Moguls and then to the Brits. But technically speaking, I am of royal blood. So there.
ReplyDeleteInteresting. I ws unaware of the predilection of the Johore Sultanate to wed into Caucasian blood. A friend of ours (and distant relative) is a close relative of the Johorean Royal Family - I must ask her about this. Maybe indulge in a little leg-pulling, too!
Deletewhen they were young, i gave my kids advice all the time, still do when asked
ReplyDeletewhen others ask what to do about so-and-so situations, i may offer my view... except in 'romantic' situations... when i tell them they're on their own!
born in a republic, i could give a rat's ass about 'royals', if they leave me alone, could care less what they do, or not
have challenged 'authority' since prepubescent times... still do... nor do i trust 'experts' - other than those like my doctors, lawyers, tradesmen, etc. who have earned my trust....
Giving children advice is acceptable because they have no life experience to make judgements. All our own decisions are based on our own peceptions stored in long term memory - that is what we call 'experience'.
DeleteThis originates from the survival mode that we have had for (millions of) years based on, "Has this happened before, what did we do on that occasion? If it was successful (clearly it was or we should not have survived!) then we will do that again." We use that today all the time particularly when driving.
With children they need to be guided along the path that we choose for them; their future is coloured by our actions and, of course, advice.
As regards 'Royalty'. I am not a 'Royalist'. On the other hand I recognise that it is important for countries like Great Britain, Malaysia, Netherlands, to have some rallying point; something that will give a strength to their traditions. Not to mention, of course, the income derived by tourism from having famous Royalty.
The US, and other republics, also have their own form of aristocracy--Royalty, if you will. In such places it is often referred to as 'Old Money'. But, still, how often have you known that certain people 'get away' with things that 'lesser mortals' do not? This is due to social standing and position (rank).
This was (is?) even true in Communist states.
Now define whart a Republic is. We shall then defuse the idea that you live in a democracy.
Ex = 'used to be'
Spurt = 'drip under pressure'